No Duels - Do not participate in any battle that has predetermined rules

We emphasise the paradoxical logic inherent in warfare, where often the direct approach is not the most effective one, and where the expected move might lead to one's downfall.

Distinguishing Duel from Conflict

A crucial distinction often overlooked in the understanding of combat is the difference between a duel and a conflict or war. A duel is a simple, controlled engagement, often governed by a strict set of rules and limited in time and scope. It is a contained event, where the parameters are known, and the outcomes are relatively predictable. This controlled environment allows for a certain level of preparation and strategy that is specific to the conditions of the duel.

In contrast, a conflict or war is a complex, multifaceted phenomenon that defies simple categorization. It is not constrained by a set of predetermined rules and is often unpredictable in its duration and evolution. The nature of conflict is such that it encompasses a wide range of variables – from the physical and tactical to the psychological and moral. Unlike a duel, where the focus is on individual skill within a known framework, a conflict demands a broader strategic understanding that accounts for the myriad unpredictable factors that can influence the outcome.

This distinction is vital in both martial arts training and military strategy. While the skills honed in a duel-like scenario are valuable, they represent only a fraction of what is required in a real-world conflict. The latter demands a more holistic approach, one that incorporates adaptability, strategic thinking, and an understanding of the complex interplay of various factors that go beyond the straightforward mechanics of a duel. Recognizing this difference is key to preparing for and effectively navigating the unpredictable nature of real conflict.

The Paradoxical Nature of Strategy

In martial arts, as in warfare, the expectation of certain rules or patterns can be a significant hindrance. A predetermined set of rules in a battle implies a limitation in tactics and strategies. It restricts the practitioner to a set framework, potentially inhibiting creativity, adaptability, and the element of surprise – all crucial aspects of effective combat strategy.

In a real conflict, as opposed to a duel like situation, there are no rules except the ultimate goal of survival and victory. The most successful strategies often come from thinking creatively, from doing the unexpected, and from adapting to the fluid nature of conflict.

The Element of Surprise

In a battle with predetermined rules, the element of surprise is drastically reduced. Both parties know what to expect and prepare accordingly. However, real-world conflicts are rarely so predictable. The ability to adapt, to change tactics mid-battle, and to use unconventional methods often determines the outcome of a conflict.

Adaptability and Fluidity

In a controlled environment with set rules, one prepares for specific scenarios. However, real conflict is chaotic and unpredictable. The ability to adapt to changing circumstances, to shift tactics and strategies in response to the enemy’s moves, is crucial. This adaptability is at the heart of Ninjutsu philosophy, where rigid adherence to a single style or set of techniques can be a significant disadvantage.

The Psychological Aspect

In a battle with predetermined rules, the psychological warfare is set. However, in an open conflict, the ability to demoralize the opponent, to create uncertainty and fear, is a powerful tool. This aspect is also seen in AKBAN Ninjutsu where the mental state of the practitioner is as important as their physical skills.

Conclusion

In both martial arts and military strategy, success often comes from the ability to think beyond the conventional, to adapt to the ever-changing dynamics of conflict, and to understand that in real battles, the only rule is that there are no rules.

Go back to reading the other mondo in Yossi Sheriff Quotes